Why include hybrid securities in an investment portfolio?

Steve Anagnos
Steve Anagnos
Shaw Co-Head, Income Strategies
Over the last 20 years the question we are asked is are hybrids equity or debt securities. The answer is neither.

Although they have features and characteristics of both ordinary equities (shares) and debt (bonds) they are actually their own asset class.  

They have a very different short term and long term risk and return profile to other asset classes.  

Treating hybrids as their own asset class and therefore their own allocation to an income (or growth) portfolio, as opposed to trying to fit into either of the traditional asset class allows investors the ability to take advantage of the opportunities the asset class offers.  It’s all about diversifying the risk of temporary or permanent loss (or drawdown) to the capital value of the portfolio whilst seeking an income return.

Hybrid securities generally provide higher yields than debt to compensate for the higher investment risk. Hybrid securities pay a regular fixed or floating rate of return or dividend (including franking credits) until a certain date. In this regard, holders are paid interest or a dividend for holding the security for a predetermined period. 

At maturity or on a reset date, the issuer may have the right to decide one of the following options:

convert the hybrid securities into the underlying equity of the issuer;
redeem the hybrid securities, usually at face value; or
roll into another hybrid structure or even a combination of the above.

Hybrids can take the form of Converting Preference Shares, Step-up Securities, Convertible Notes and Perpetual Income Securities. Each has different risk and reward characteristics, and by blending security types, issuer quality, maturities, as well as securities trading at a premium/discount to face value, a number of bespoke outcomes can be created to offset ordinary equity risk in a portfolio, whilst generating sustainable and predictable returns.

Investors often focus on yield maximisation as their main investment objective. As a result, many investment portfolios hold a substantial allocation to high dividend equities. Such a narrow focus without consideration of encompassing the full universe of available and suitable investments may potentially result in an unexpected and permanent drawdown. It’s interesting that over the last 12 months the holding period returns have been higher in a portfolio of major bank hybrids as compares to holding the underlying shares.

By understanding the dynamics and relative returns and risks of the complete capital structure (debt and hybrids), and appropriately allocating to this sector, as well as individual securities, investors with clearly identifiable investment objectives are able to maximise the likelihood of achieving these objectives. 


Must admit, I'm a novice when it comes to hybrids. Looking forward to learning more from the guys at Shaws

Thanks, this was interesting

Learn more
With a national presence and over $18 billion of assets under advice, Shaw and Partners offers the intimacy of a boutique investment firm, backed by the resources and scale of a major financial group, EFG International.

At Shaw and Partners, we offer tailored advice and investment solutions, financial planning and corporate advisory services. We act for and on behalf of individuals, institutions, corporates and charities. We are client-focused, having helped our clients manage and grow their financial assets for over 30 years. Our emphasis on integrity has enabled us to achieve very high levels of client satisfaction while unlocking opportunities of significant value.

Backed by fresh thinking, robust research and some of the nation’s best investment and wealth experts, our business has been designed to meet the growing needs of our clients. Shaw and Partners offers access to an extensive team of private client advisers, institutional sales and trading specialists, market-leading research analysts and strategic corporate financiers.

By working closely with clients and targeting their needs, we have forged strong long-term relationships. So, whether you are an ordinary investor, high net worth individual, charity, institution or corporate, our goal is simple: to listen to you, then act according to your needs alone.